• SERVICES
  • INDUSTRIES
  • PERSPECTIVES
  • ABOUT

    • Who We Are

      We support businesses in their strategic decisions on growth and optimization

      Who We Are

    • Connect With Us

      let’s connect to discuss how we could support your intelligence needs

      Contact

    • Work With EOS

      We are researchers – curious, knowledge-hungry, and eager to solve problems

      Work With Us
  • Search
  • ENGAGE

TECHNOLOGY

Home TECHNOLOGY

Mind over Matter How Non-invasive Neuromodulation Is Becoming the Future of Pain Management by EOS Intelligence
by EOS Intelligence EOS Intelligence No Comments

Mind over Matter: How Non-invasive Neuromodulation Is Becoming the Future of Pain Management and Beyond

Scientists have been researching the possibility of using electrical impulses to treat many health conditions. The starting point was the introduction of the first TENS (transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation) device in the 1970s in the USA. Its goal was to test the tolerance of chronic pain patients to electrical stimulation. In recent years, non-invasive neuromodulation has emerged as a promising field for treating various neurological disorders. This field will likely experience significant growth in the coming decade, thanks to technological advancements, such as AI-powered sophisticated wearables.

Non-invasive neuromodulation is emerging as a novel treatment for several diseases

Non-invasive neuromodulation is a technique that uses external devices to apply electromagnetic fields, electrical currents, or other forms of stimulation to the brain to enable targeted modulation of neural activity.

The technique is effective in treating a range of conditions. Currently, several devices are available in the market for treating illnesses, including chronic pain, tinnitus, diabetic neuropathy, and functional disorders such as bladder and bowel control.

The non-invasive neuromodulation market encompasses a diverse array of devices that can modify neural activity without the need for invasive procedures. This includes transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS), transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS), and TENS.

TMS therapy sessions typically require the presence of a physician. An example is MagVenture Pain Therapy, a TMS device developed by a Denmark-based company, MagVenture, for treating chronic pain.

TENS and tDCS devices are portable and, hence, suitable for at-home treatments. The FDA has not yet approved tDCS in the USA for medical use. However, its use falls under the Investigational Device Exception (IDA) regulations. Though it is marketed for non-medical uses in the USA, it is used for medical treatment in regions such as the EU, Singapore, and Israel.

TENS devices are small, battery-powered devices that consist of leads that connect to electrodes, sticky pads placed on the skin in the area that needs stimulation. An example is Cefaly, an FDA-approved TENS device developed by the US-based Cefaly Technology for pain management. This device works by stimulating and desensitizing the primary source of migraine pain, the trigeminal nerve, using a precise electrical impulse.

Mind over Matter How Non-invasive Neuromodulation Is Becoming the Future by EOS Intelligence

Mind over Matter How Non-invasive Neuromodulation Is Becoming the Future by EOS Intelligence

The non-invasive neuromodulation market is showing rapid growth

The global non-invasive neuromodulation devices market for neurological and psychiatric disorders was approximately US$1.2 billion in 2022. According to a 2023 report by Report Prime, an India-based market research firm, the market is projected to grow at a CAGR of 7.2% from 2023 to 2030, reaching US$2.1 billion by 2030.

Several reasons fuel this rapid growth in recent years, including the increasing prevalence of chronic pain and other neurological conditions (especially in older patients), the numerous advantages this technique has over invasive neuromodulation, breakthroughs in non-invasive technology, and a surge in investments.

Increasing incidence of neurological disorders is a major driver

The increasing incidence of debilitating disorders such as chronic pain, Parkinson’s disease, diabetic neuropathy, etc., is creating a pressing need for new and efficient treatments to address these conditions. A 2023 study by the CDC indicated that 20.9% of American adults suffered from chronic pain, and 6.9% experienced chronic pain that significantly limited their daily activities.

Similarly, Parkinson’s disease affects nearly 1 million people in the USA as of 2023, with this number expected to rise to 1.2 million by 2030. These statistics indicate a rising trend of neurological disease burden in the USA.

One major issue that many patients and physicians face is that the current treatments for many of these conditions fall short, leaving a significant gap in the care of patients. Typically, doctors treat people suffering from chronic pain, including that of diabetic neuropathy, using painkillers. Most patients develop medicine tolerance, experience drug-wearing-off effects, or suffer from severe side effects, diminishing the overall treatment effectiveness.

Some patients may even consider drastic and irreversible surgical procedures, such as nerve amputation, due to inadequate treatment results. However, even these may not always provide the desired relief. This indicates the need for a reliable and effective solution for managing the pain, discomfort, and other neurological symptoms associated with the primary disease.

As non-invasive neuromodulation stimulates the brain areas responsible for pain processing, it alters the patient’s perception of pain. With the growing incidence of neurological disorders, this desired neuromodulation effect will continue to be in high demand, contributing to the growth of the non-invasive neuromodulation devices market.

Non-invasive treatments offer advantages over other techniques

Typically, conditions such as chronic pain are treated using a combination of prescription medicines. However, these medications, including NSAIDs, opioids, etc., come with a variety of side effects, such as digestive issues, ulcers, drowsiness, etc. Long-term use of opioids can lead to a range of negative consequences, including the development of tolerance, physical dependence, and opioid use disorder, increasing the risk of overdose and death. Conventional treatment methods also need frequent hospital visits.

Invasive neuromodulation is an effective treatment option for various neurological conditions. However, it also carries significant risks, such as site infections, perioperative and postoperative complications, blood clots, and device malfunctions. Additionally, these techniques often require multiple hospital visits.

In contrast, non-invasive neuromodulation offers several advantages over invasive methods. These wearable devices provide drug-free treatments that do not require surgery or complex installation. As a result, they are easy for patients and physicians to use.

A comprehensive study about the efficacy of various non-invasive devices is not yet available. However, controlled individual studies by companies and developers have shown promising efficiency in treating various diseases.

Moreover, a 2019 report published in BMJ, a peer-reviewed medical journal, indicated that non-invasive neuromodulation offers a potential solution for patients who are sensitive to traditional treatments. This includes patient groups such as pregnant women, adolescents, and those who experience poor tolerability or lack of efficacy from pharmacological treatment therapies.

The need to treat health conditions of these patient groups may drive the use of non-invasive devices to treat health conditions.

Scientific advancements help improve efficacy and expand applications

The non-invasive neuromodulation field has seen several breakthroughs in recent years, showing promise for accelerated R&D and new and improved devices potentially entering the market in the future.

One example is the proprietary magnetic peripheral nerve stimulation (mPNS), marketed as Axon Therapy, developed in 2023 by US-based Neuralace Medical for managing painful diabetic neuropathy.

Another example is vibrotactile stimulation (VTS), currently under development by an interdisciplinary research team from the University of Minnesota as a treatment for spasmodic torticollis or cervical dystonia. This is a painful neurological condition that affects the neck. Though the product is not yet marketable, the clinical trials are showing significant promise.

VTS devices are also being developed for conditions other than pain. An example is the VTS glove, a wearable device developed by researchers at Stanford University and the Georgia Institute of Technology in 2024. The device applies high-frequency vibrations to the hands and fingers to relieve uncontrollable arm and hand spasms. In clinical trials, patients who used the device experienced significant improvements in symptoms, with some even reporting a reduction in their use of oral medications. The team is now working to develop the device further and make it available to patients as a publicly available therapy.

Furthermore, a new treatment for tinnitus, known as bimodal neuromodulation, which involves stimulating two sensory pathways in the brain, has been developed. Ireland-based company Neuromod offers the Lenire device, which combines headphones and a mouthpiece to deliver auditory and tactile stimuli to alleviate symptoms. Patients wear the device for an hour daily, for at least six weeks, to stimulate the tongue with electrical impulses while listening to tones.

These new developments are likely to give momentum to the ongoing R&D in the sector.

Increased investment signals growing market potential

The sector has also seen an uptick in investments. For example, Nalu Medical, a US-based company, secured US$65 million in funding in 2024 to advance its neurostimulation technology for treating chronic pain.

Similarly, Avation Medical, a US-based company focusing on treating bladder issues, raised over US$22 million in 2024 to launch the Vivally System. This wearable device treats patients with urge urinary incontinence (UUI) and overactive bladder (OAB) syndrome.

Massachusetts–based Cognito Therapeutics, a company focused on developing a new therapy for Alzheimer’s disease, raised around US$73 million in 2023.

This increasing trend in R&D investments shows investors’ rising interest in the field of non-invasive neuromodulation, indicating promising market prospects.

Integration with AI is expected to pave the way for future developments

Non-invasive neuromodulation is seeing considerable success in developing closed-loop systems that leverage artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) to give customized therapeutic output. This trend is likely to see more growth, especially with the rapid advancements in the field of AI.

An example is Avation Medical’s Vivally System, a wearable neuromodulation device that uses closed-loop, autonomously adjusted electrical stimulation to treat patients with UUI and OAB syndrome. The device uses a smartphone app to calibrate itself for each patient and then delivers a constant current of electrical stimulation through a wearable garment. It also uses an advanced AI-powered closed-loop algorithm and electromyography (a medical test that measures the electrical signals sent by nerves to muscles and received back from them) to enable continuous real-time monitoring and therapy adjustment, ensuring uniformity and safety.

Non-invasive neuromodulation device companies are forming partnerships with research institutes to develop safe ways to treat various disorders using generative AI neuromodulation.

One such collaboration started in June 2024 between US-Swiss generative neuromodulation firm, Dandelion Science and Geneva-based research institute Wyss Center for Bio and Neuroengineering. The goal is to develop a generative AI neuromodulation platform for treating neurodegenerative and neuropsychiatric disorders.

Similar collaborations are likely to commence in the future, as it is clear that the combination of neuromodulation and AI is set to impact various treatment fields significantly.

Expansion of insurance coverage could boost treatment accessibility

Conventionally, chronic pain treatment involves a combination of drugs and physical therapy. The US patient usually pays 20% of their Medicare-approved amount. People with severe pain spend about US$7,700 on annual healthcare expenditures, and with insurance, they have to spend around US$1,600 annually. For the management of pain conditions such as migraine, the out-of-pocket expense can increase to 30% of their Medicare-approved amount.

Non-invasive neuromodulation treatment has proved to be more cost-effective than conventional treatments. Although many non-invasive pain management devices are not covered by insurance, some are eligible for reimbursement.

For instance, Nerivio, a wearable device for treating migraine, is covered by Medicaid and Highmark Insurance. Moreover, Theranica, Nerivio’s Israel-based parent company, introduced the Nerivio Savings Program in October 2020 to help US patients access the device. It is a reimbursement plan that allows patients to receive their first device for a copay of up to US$49 (for 18 treatments), depending on their insurance coverage. The refill costs US$89 for those without insurance.

Additionally, patients may be able to use Health Savings Accounts (HSAs) or Flexible Spending Accounts (FSAs) to pay for specific approved devices. An example is Cefaly, for which, though not covered by insurance in the USA, consumers can use HSA and FSA funds or finance their purchase with Affirm (a US-based financial technology company that offers flexible payment options) for US$36 per month upon qualifying. Without insurance or other financial aid, the upfront cost varies from US$330 to US$430, and an additional US$25 for three reusable electrodes, each usable up to 20 times each.

Non-invasive neuromodulation devices’ high upfront cost remains the key barrier to broader adoption 

Overall, non-invasive neuromodulation devices offer a more cost-effective option than other treatments. The most significant barrier for patients opting for non-invasive neuromodulation is the high upfront cost, especially with no insurance coverage.

For example, Israel-based Zida Therapeutics’ Zida Control Sock, a device to treat urinary incontinence, comes with an upfront cost of US$750. Without insurance, many people may find it challenging to cover this cost. This is particularly true for older adults whom conditions such as chronic pain and urinary incontinence affect the most. According to 2023 data released by the US Census Bureau, 14.1% of Americans aged 65 and older live in poverty, making these devices less accessible to them without insurance coverage.

However, this situation may improve as several companies are now in talks to receive insurance coverage for their devices. With an increase in R&D, companies can also offer robust evidence to demonstrate the effectiveness and long-term safety of the devices, prompting insurance companies to provide coverage.

With reimbursement available for companies such as Theranica and Zida, and with several other companies such as Neurovalens planning to enter discussions with insurance providers to achieve reimbursement status, the accessibility has a chance to improve in the near future. This will likely drive adoption in the coming years.

EOS Perspective

Adopting non-invasive devices will likely increase as a standalone treatment and adjunct therapy. While non-invasive treatments currently focus on conditions such as chronic pain, tinnitus, urinary incontinence, etc., experts believe that this will soon expand into other neurological conditions, including ALS, and Parkinson’s disease.

Currently, there are only seven FDA-approved drugs for ALS treatment, all of them with limited effectiveness. The significant unmet need in this field presents a compelling opportunity for non-invasive neuromodulation companies. Cognito Therapeutics and PathMaker Neurosystems are among the few companies conducting feasibility studies and developing non-invasive neuromodulation treatment options for ALS patients.

Research is also underway to develop a non-invasive treatment for Parkinson’s disease, which was previously treated using invasive techniques. Czech Republic-based STIMVIA has reported promising results from its initial pilot study of a new treatment for patients with Parkinson’s disease as an add-on therapy.

Several new non-invasive devices are also in the development pipeline, and their clinical trials are promising. An example that has shown positive results in a pivotal trial is a treatment for improving upper limb function by Netherlands-based ONWARD Medicals.

Non-invasive neuromodulation has the potential to revolutionize the treatment of chronic pain and other neurological disorders. As the field continues to evolve, with advancements in AI-powered wearables and increased investment in R&D, we can expect to see even more innovative solutions emerge in the coming years.

Neuromarketing How Brands Are Leveraging Brain Science to Decode Your Desires by EOS Intelligence
by EOS Intelligence EOS Intelligence No Comments

Neuromarketing: How Brands Are Leveraging Brain Science to Decode Your Desires

Innovative marketing strategies have become highly important for businesses in today’s crowded markets, where there is abundant competition and consumers have a vast array of options. This is why neuromarketing, a concept where brain science meets marketing, has started gaining popularity. Christened “astonishing hypothesis” by Nobel Laureate Francis Crick, it holds great promise for current and future marketers.

Neuromarketing is a marketing strategy that uses scientific methods to understand how consumers’ brains respond to products and advertisements. It measures brain activity and how people subconsciously react to ads, packaging, and products using methods such as electroencephalography (EEG), functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), and eye tracking.

The goal is to uncover the underlying motivations, preferences, and decision-making processes that drive customer behavior. This approach can help marketers and businesses create more effective advertisements, develop products that meet customer needs and wants, and set appealing prices.

The concept of neuromarketing has been around since the 1990s and it gained popularity with the development techniques such as the Zaltman metaphor elicitation technique. This method allows researchers to tap into a person’s conscious and unconscious thoughts by analyzing their metaphoric or non-literal expressions.

Companies are using various approaches to adopt neuromarketing

Neuromarketing campaigns can use numerous approaches to attract customers.

EEGs and fMRIs are becoming increasingly popular

One approach is to use brain scanning techniques such as fMRI or EEG to monitor brain activity and understand how people process information.

An example is the 2011 neuromarketing study by the South Korean automotive manufacturer Hyundai. The company measured brain activity using EEG and identified the design features most likely stimulating a desire to buy. Based on the study, Hyundai also modified the exterior design of its cars.

Another one is the 2011 commercial Yahoo rolled out to attract more users to its search engine. Before launching the US$100 million rebranding campaign, the company tested the 60-second commercial featuring happy people dancing worldwide. The company had people wear EEG caps to monitor their brain activity while watching the ad to gauge its impact. The results showed that the ad stimulated activity in areas of the brain associated with memory and emotional response, suggesting it could effectively grab viewers’ attention.

Similarly, Microsoft partnered with California-based market research company EmSense in 2009 to study the brain activity of Xbox gamers to understand how engaged they are when exposed to 30- and 60-second TV ads versus in-game ads on the Xbox. The study, using EEG technology, showed that the highest level of brain activity occurred during the first half of TV ads promoting an automotive brand. Also, brain activity decreased when the same ad was repeated during Xbox Live in-game advertising. Microsoft incorporated this format to improve the ad’s memorability.

Businesses such as Frito-Lay, a US-based snack manufacturer, use EEG and focus groups to assess consumers’ genuine reactions to new advertisements. In a 2008 ad, they showed a woman pranking her friend by filling her laundry with orange Cheetos. Despite the focus group participants expressing a dislike for the ad, an EEG study revealed that they actually found it enjoyable.

The EEG-based neuromarketing trend will likely gain even more traction, especially with wearable EEG devices becoming increasingly common. In 2011, Tokyo-based multinational conglomerate Hitachi developed a portable, wearable brain scanner that neuromarketing can employ. Users can wear it while performing everyday activities, such as shopping, allowing marketers to study consumer behavior and preferences in real-life settings. This will also help them to develop marketing campaigns aligned with consumer preferences.

Neuromarketing How Brands Are Leveraging Brain Science to Decode Your Desires by EOS Intelligence

Neuromarketing How Brands Are Leveraging Brain Science to Decode Your Desires by EOS Intelligence

Marketers track eyes to identify customer preferences

Eye-tracking technology is another important technique used in neuromarketing. This technology records the movement of a person’s eyes as they view a screen, generating a heat map to show where they focused their attention. This method can be used to compare the effectiveness of different ads.

A 2009 study conducted by Objective Experience, a Singapore-based research firm, found that when people are shown a diaper ad with a baby looking directly at them, they pay less attention to the message. However, when the baby looks at the ad content, people engage more with the message.

Companies such as UK-based Unilever frequently use this method to test how their products perform in-store. In 2016, it partnered with Swedish technology company Tobii to record shoppers’ attention data while browsing products on the shelf using wearable eye trackers. The data was then analyzed to identify the features that drew shoppers’ attention, how they interacted with branding and marketing elements, and their impact on customer behavior. The insights from this study helped Unilever determine the design features that resonate most with shoppers, allowing the company to optimize brand awareness and perception.

Many other companies have also experimented with eye-tracking techniques. In 2017, the Japanese automotive manufacturer Toyota collaborated with Tobii to improve its in-store experience. The study revealed that younger shoppers spent more time on interactive digital elements, while older shoppers focused on textual information. However, it also showed that interactive digital screens generated the most engagement. This study became very beneficial for Toyota. Since consumers, such as automobile buyers, visit showrooms to make a specific purchase, eye-tracking technology can directly impact the sales of such companies.

While Unilever and Toyota collaborated with Tobii on neuromarketing strategies, UK-based pharmaceutical giant GlaxoSmithKline (GSK) has developed an in-house technique. In 2017, it launched a “Consumer Sensory Lab” to test its products using eye-tracking technology. The lab is designed to mimic a real store, allowing consumers to browse and shop while being monitored by eye-tracking devices. This allows GSK to analyze how consumers interact with products on the shelf and what packaging elements catch their attention. GSK’s investment in this technology shows that big players are now considering leveraging neuromarketing for market research and product development.

Packaging, colors, and emotions are essential in neuromarketing

Many companies are using effective packaging and experimenting with color psychology in neuromarketing. In 2009, Frito-Lay partnered with Ontario-based Juniper Park to understand why women were not choosing their products. The company identified that its shiny packaging was generating feelings of guilt in women while snacking. They redesigned their packaging using softer colors and avoided language that might trigger guilt.

Several companies use certain colors as neuromarketing tools to evoke specific emotions. US-based Coca-Cola’s use of the color red is an example. Similarly, brands such as Target and Netflix use red to convey feelings of power, excitement, and passion. Red has also been linked to increased hunger. Many fast-food chains, such as Wendy’s and KFC, use red to increase client engagement.

Many businesses also try to increase engagement by bringing out specific emotions. An example is German auto manufacturer Volkswagen’s 2011 Super Bowl ad, featuring a young boy dressed as Darth Vader trying to use “the force” on a VW Passat. Experts attributed the ad’s success to its combination of nostalgia (Star Wars), empathy (parental love), and humor (Darth Vader’s reaction).

Another example is Frito Lay’s 2018 “Operation Smile” campaign, which featured a series of smiles on the packaging of its potato chips. The campaign was designed to bring joy and happiness to customers and successfully connect with them.

Many brands are redesigning their packages and presentations using neuromarketing feedback, and the trend is expected to continue in the future.

AI integration and emotion AI are the emerging trends in the market

Integration with AI is one emerging trend that is greatly benefiting neuromarketing. As consumers engage in various online platforms, including social media, they leave a digital trail of personal information. This can be accessed by AI programs stored in the cloud.

AI analyzes this data and identifies patterns and customer preferences. This information can then be used to create effective marketing strategies. Netflix, for example, uses AI to power its recommendation engine and suggest shows based on users’ viewing history, completion rates, popularity rankings, etc.

AI also plays a crucial role in facial recognition and emotion detection. AI-driven facial tracking technologies are expected to help marketers understand how people respond emotionally to ad content more efficiently and accurately, helping them to design more engaging and impactful experiences.

Emotion AI, a type of artificial intelligence that analyzes, responds to, and simulates human emotions by detecting and interpreting emotional signals from various sources such as text, audio, and video, is another technological trend expected to benefit neuromarketing. Since this technology can capture and analyze human emotions and body language, marketers can use it to create user-centered and empathetic advertisements.

Sentiment analysis is an example, a tool used by Emotion AI that analyzes human emotions in text. This is often employed in marketing functions such as product review analysis.

An example is a 2018 campaign by the American sportswear giant Nike. The company used sentiment analysis to navigate the controversy surrounding NFL player Colin Kaepernick’s “take a knee” protest. As public opinion was divided, with both critics and supporters voicing their views, Nike partnered with California-based software development company Sentieo to monitor customer sentiments to protect its reputation. They tracked tweets and news related to the campaign before and after incorporating the “#justdoit” hashtag in Kaepernick’s tweets. The analysis also showed that consumer purchase intent improved due to the campaign, which benefited Nike.

Using tools such as Emotion AI is expected to directly affect companies’ profits since it helps them easily identify the customer’s opinion about the brand. It can also be used to detect early warning signs of customer dissatisfaction or frustration. This is expected to enable businesses to address issues promptly and reduce the risk of negative word-of-mouth or online reviews.

There are challenges and concerns about adoption

Though neuromarketing is expected to shape the future of marketing, interested players must address some concerns before taking the plunge. Critics have raised ethical concerns about its morality and the potential for privacy violations. There is also a potential for bias and inaccuracies in the research methods, leading to unreliable conclusions and flawed marketing strategies.

Larger companies with greater budgets are more likely to use neuromarketing leaving smaller players, who cannot afford the cost, at a significant disadvantage. This will widen the gap between these companies, as smaller ones will struggle to compete with larger companies’ marketing and advertising capabilities. Also, consumers may unknowingly choose products influenced by neuromarketing tactics, making it even harder for smaller companies to compete.

Moreover, larger corporations will have the means to invest in research and development of own neuromarketing techniques, further solidifying their advantage. These companies are also likely to keep the research findings proprietary, thereby limiting opportunities for smaller companies to compete.

More research is also needed to bring neuromarketing to the mainstream, especially in areas where real-time responses and feedback are required, such as in-store shopping. Since EEG technology, widely used in neuromarketing, can be compromised by interference from other electrical devices and requires subjects to remain still, it can become difficult to replicate lab-based research conditions in a real-world setting.

EOS Perspective

The marketing landscape has significantly transformed in the past few years. Consumers are now more tech-savvy and take to social media platforms when faced with an unpleasant event. Companies are also aware that negative reviews on online platforms can significantly impact a brand’s reputation within a short time. This can be increasingly managed by employing neuromarketing. Though it is still considered to be in its embryonic stage, experts believe this innovative marketing technique will reshape advertising and consumer-business relationships.

As the number of global mobile users is expected to cross 7.5 billion in 2025, according to a 2021 report by the US-based market research firm, The Radicati Group, neuromarketers are expected to collect real-time data by leveraging mobile devices. This will enable players to capture a more authentic and nuanced understanding of consumer behavior in real-world settings rather than relying solely on laboratory-based or controlled environments.

This real-time data collected using mobile devices can be used to design marketing strategies, product development, and customer experiences that are more tailored to meet consumers’ evolving needs and preferences.

Experts also believe that technological advancements such as brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) can revolutionize the marketing landscape in the near future. BCIs enable seamless communication between the human brain and machines, giving marketers access to consumers’ real-time thoughts and emotions. This is expected to pave the way for ultra-personalization, as companies can tailor their products and advertisements to individuals’ unique preferences and emotional responses.

While there are ethical concerns surrounding its use, the fact that neuromarketing is still in its early stages of development means it has the potential to evolve in tandem with addressing the ethical doubts. As technology becomes more accessible, the key challenge will be ensuring that neuromarketing is used responsibly and ethically.

What’s Fueling Asia’s Drive to Develop Wholesale CBDCs by EOS Intelligence
by EOS Intelligence EOS Intelligence No Comments

What’s Fueling Asia’s Drive to Develop Wholesale CBDCs?

The emergence of Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs) has become a central focus in the global financial space, as it offers the potential for revolutionary shifts in how the world conducts and manages monetary transactions. While much of the spotlight has been on retail CBDCs, wholesale CBDCs are gaining momentum globally. Asia is leading the pack in developing wholesale CBDCs that offer opportunities that may significantly impact the global financial landscape.

Asia is outpacing developed countries in the drive toward wholesale CBDCs

Wholesale CBDCs are digital forms of a country’s fiat currency. Unlike retail CBDCs, only a limited number of entities can access wholesale CBDCs, which are designed for undertaking interbank transactions and settlements. The concept of wholesale CBDCs is similar to currently available digital assets used for the settlement of interbank transactions, with the key differentiation being the use of technologies such as distributed ledger technology (DLT) and tokenization.

Wholesale CBDCs have garnered global interest with central banks. Facebook’s (albeit failed) attempt to launch its Libra cryptocurrency in 2019 was a breaking point for blockchain technology’s use in global finance, eventually spurring the development of wholesale CBDCs. Initially launched as a measure to counter private cryptocurrencies, wholesale CBDCs are fast emerging as a potential disruptor in the fintech space.

Currently, more than 30 countries are researching the use of wholesale CBDCs. Interestingly, about half of these countries are from Asia. The development of wholesale CBDCs in Asian countries has outpaced the efforts of financially strong economies such as the USA and the UK, as these CBDCs offer more tangible benefits to developing economies in Asia than their more developed counterparts.

Several Asian countries have engaged in pilot programs, and proof-of-concept runs to explore the use of wholesale CBDCs to improve the efficiency of domestic large-value transactions and cross-border transfers.

China has been at the forefront of the development and widespread testing of wholesale CBDCs. Several Southeast Asia and the Middle East countries, including India, the UAE, Thailand, and Singapore, have launched pilot programs to explore the viability of wholesale CBDCs and test interoperability for cross-border transactions.

Achieving faster and cheaper cross-border transactions is key to Asian central banks

Growth in global trade has resulted in exponential growth in cross-border transaction volumes. However, these cross-border transactions are faced with challenges. There may be involvement of potential intermediaries, varying time zones, and regulatory frictions that may cause slower settlement. Financial systems such as SWIFT have a stranglehold on the cross-border transaction ecosystem, with many of these transactions using SWIFT messaging to settle payments.

Potential intermediary fees and forex-related charges also lead to increased transaction costs. According to World Bank’s estimates, transaction costs for cross-border transactions may range up to 6% of the transfer value, a significant surcharge.

Removing friction associated with cross-border transactions is a key goal behind Asian countries’ push toward exploring wholesale CBDCs.

A growing interest in wholesale CBDCs is attracting investments in building large-value payment infrastructures in Asia, allowing for faster and more efficient cross-border transfers. Wholesale CBDCs enable central banks to transact directly with each other, removing the involvement of multiple intermediaries and resulting in quicker transaction settlement. This also results in the elimination of intermediary fees to help lower transaction costs.

Technology also adds elements of security and traceability to these digital transactions. It also offers the potential to program them by automating or restricting payments if certain conditions are met.

Challenging US dollar dominance in cross-border settlements offers additional motivation

Several Asian countries are also looking to reduce their reliance on financial settlement systems that involve US dollar reserves. Currently, most cross-border transactions involve the use of the US dollar. Countries with limited forex reserves also face the challenge of outgoing reserves, resulting in potential currency inflation and adding to the already high transaction costs.

Wholesale CBDCs offer several Asian countries, particularly those with limited US dollar reserves, an opportunity to directly transfer the amount in their local digital currencies and eliminate the need for US dollars in bilateral transactions.

Developing Asian economies, such as China and India, with significant cross-border transactions, are looking to promote their CBDCs as a potential reserve currency in the Asian region that would allow cross-border settlement directly in the digital currency. It is also in the interests of countries such as China to develop its CBDC (e-CNY) as a potential alternative to the US Dollar in cross-border trade to mitigate any potential currency-related challenges posed by economic sanctions from the USA and EU.

What’s Fueling Asia’s Drive to Develop Wholesale CBDCs by EOS Intelligence

What’s Fueling Asia’s Drive to Develop Wholesale CBDCs by EOS Intelligence

Tandem development and collaborations offer tailwinds to CBDC projects in Asia

Central banks of several Asian countries are undertaking information sharing and tandem development of CBDC infrastructures to mitigate some challenges associated with CBDC.

Recent pilot projects such as mBridge, launched by central banks of China, the UAE, Thailand, and Hong Kong, have been testing the use of a common ledger platform for real-time peer-to-peer transactions. The launch of several other projects, such as Project Mandala (involving Singapore, South Korea, and Malaysia) and Project Aber (involving Saudi Arabia and the UAE), is laying the groundwork for the widespread implementation of wholesale CBDCs.

Another potential avenue for collaboration includes forming partnerships with central banks to maintain reserves of digital cash to facilitate direct settlement. China, in particular, plans to develop e-CNY as a potential reserve currency alternative to the US dollar.

Interoperability and ownership are key challenges to CBDC implementation

While the use of wholesale CBDCs certainly comes forward as a boon, there are challenges in using these technology-driven digital currencies. CBDCs may have varying protocols, and interoperability between different CBDC frameworks remains a key challenge for implementing wholesale CBDCs for cross-border transactions.

Establishing common technical and operational standards is essential to ensure CBDC interoperability. Currently, most pilot programs involve CBDCs with common or similar technological frameworks and rules, which limit the application of wholesale CBDCs to a certain number of compatible entities.

Recent research projects are laying the groundwork for CBDCs’ compatibility with various ledgers and technical frameworks. However, significant testing will be required before compatibility can be established across the Asian region.

Ownership, governance, and regulatory oversight of wholesale CBDC technologies are other key concerns. Doubts exist over who will oversee the transactions and ledger entries, especially for any multi-party cross-border transaction.

Systems must also to adhere to anti-money laundering and counter-terrorism financing regulations. Varying financial laws may also hamper the seamless implementation of these anti-money laundering and counter-threat funding regulations across the region.

Lastly, like any digital asset, CBDCs are also susceptible to cyberattacks.

EOS Perspective

Wholesale CBDCs can potentially change the nature of cross-border transactions across Asia and globally.

We are likely to witness significant growth in test runs and pilot programs by several Asian countries to provide proof of concept for the applicability of wholesale CBDCs in countering the challenges associated with cross-border transactions. We can expect a spurt in CBDC alliances and treaties among countries with significant bilateral and intra-regional trade. Simultaneously, it may result in slightly reduced transaction volumes going through existing cross-border financial systems such as SWIFT.

The next stage of CBDC evolution is likely to coincide with the emergence of pilot programs involving multiple CBDCs with different technological frameworks, creating possibilities for easier and seamless cross-border transactions among banks or countries without any existing bilateral or regional partnerships.

These developments are likely to be aided by the development of enabling technologies such as RegTech (regulatory technologies) and SupTech (supervisory technologies), which could provide the sandbox environment for widespread testing of the CBDC systems, as well as lay the groundwork for potential regulatory systems to manage these infrastructures.

With the bulk of cross-border transactions still being conducted in the US dollar, wholesale CBDCs do not pose any imminent threat to its dominance. The US dollar’s future prospects in this role will depend on whether digital currencies such as e-CNY take off as a reserve currency, which is unlikely, at least in the short- to medium-term.

The overall success of wholesale CBDCs will depend on the level of cooperation that countries across Asia can develop over the next few years.

Prescribing Security Diagnosing and Treating the IoT Universe in Healthcare by EOS Intelligence
by EOS Intelligence EOS Intelligence No Comments

Prescribing Security: Diagnosing and Treating the IoT Universe in Healthcare

The integration of the Internet of Things (IoT) into the healthcare industry has significantly transformed the delivery of medical services, enhanced patient experiences, and revolutionized medical practices. While the benefits of IoT are undeniable, there are challenges that come with its adoption. Issues such as device hacking and data breaches pose significant obstacles that must be addressed. Therefore, it is essential for device manufacturers to design medical devices with caution. By taking a proactive approach and investing in robust cybersecurity measures during the design and development phases, manufacturers can create devices that are more secure and less vulnerable to hacking.

IoT has revolutionized the healthcare industry by enabling medical devices to connect and communicate with each other, as well as with healthcare providers and patients. These devices utilize cloud computing and collect valuable data in real time, allowing for remote monitoring, timely interventions, and personalized care.

The average hospital room worldwide has an estimated 15 to 20 interconnected medical devices. This number is steadily increasing due to the rising adoption of internet-connected devices. The market for IoT medical devices is close to US$40 billion as of 2023. With exponential growth, it is likely to cross US$150 billion over the next five years. This upward trajectory is geared towards reducing healthcare systems’ costs, enhancing patient care, and streamlining clinician workflows.

Healthcare organizations are not immune to cybersecurity breaches

Amid this inevitable growth in adoption, it is crucial to prioritize the security of medical devices to protect patients’ lives, safety, and privacy. While these devices have the potential to streamline and improve treatment, they also pose significant risks due to their susceptibility to cyberattacks.

According to a 2019 report by Fierce Healthcare, 82% of healthcare organizations experienced cyberattacks targeting IoT devices. Moreover, about 53% of medical and IoT devices in hospitals had vulnerabilities. Cybercriminals have honed in on the healthcare industry as a prime target, capitalizing on its perceived lack of robust cybersecurity protocols.

Healthcare bleeds out money without a cybersecurity cure

According to IBM’s Cost of a Data Breach 2023 report, the average cost of a cyberattack in the healthcare industry is US$4.45 million per breach, marking a 2.3% increase from the previous year’s average cost of US$4.35 million.

This significant uptick in costs since 2020, when the average overall cost of a data breach was US$3.86 million, represents a substantial 15.3% increase over three years. This growth underscores the importance of prioritizing cybersecurity measures to protect sensitive patient data and ensure the safety and integrity of medical devices in healthcare settings.

Unaddressed IoT challenges in medical devices lead to unauthorized access

Despite the many potential benefits of IoT medical devices in healthcare, the lack of adequate security measures continues to be one of their main challenges. Many devices do not have robust encryption protocols or authentication mechanisms, making them easy targets for hackers.

These vulnerabilities could potentially be exploited to gain unauthorized access to patient information or manipulate the device to deliver harmful treatments. As these devices become more interconnected with other healthcare systems, the potential cyberattacks only increase, posing a serious threat to patient safety.

Prescribing Security Diagnosing and Treating the IoT Universe in Healthcare by EOS Intelligence

Prescribing Security Diagnosing and Treating the IoT Universe in Healthcare by EOS Intelligence

Hackers endanger patients’ health and lives

Hackers can exploit vulnerabilities in IoT medical devices to gain access to sensitive patient information, alter treatment settings, or sabotage critical systems. This poses a grave threat to patient safety and privacy, as well as the overall integrity of healthcare infrastructure. Furthermore, since IoT devices are interconnected, a breach in one device could potentially compromise the entire network, leading to widespread disruptions and chaos in healthcare delivery.

One example of such a breach occurred in 2019 at a Springhill Medical Centre in the USA involving a ransomware attack. This attack disabled patient monitors for several days, leading to a substantial impact on patient care. A lawsuit has been filed, alleging that the disabled monitoring devices led to infant death during delivery at the center.

IoT medical devices need improved security to match technological advancements

The rapid pace of technological advancements in IoT medical devices often outpaces the development of security protocols. New features and functionalities are constantly added to these devices to improve patient care.

However, these updates may also introduce additional security vulnerabilities that cybercriminals can exploit. Many healthcare providers struggle to keep up with these evolving threats and may not have the resources or expertise to effectively secure their IoT devices on an ongoing basis.

Diversity of IoT devices complicates securing healthcare environments

The healthcare environment is characterized by a diverse range of interconnected devices, often developed by various manufacturers with varying security protocols, making it difficult to implement a cohesive security strategy across all devices. This diversity complicates efforts to achieve comprehensive visibility and security, as each device may require distinct monitoring and protection strategies.

Additionally, the sheer number of devices in use within a healthcare facility can overwhelm IT teams responsible for monitoring and securing them, increasing the likelihood of overlooking potential security risks.

Limited downtime poses cybersecurity challenges

IoT medical devices are used continuously in real time, leaving little room for downtime. This lack of downtime poses a challenge for security teams, as they have limited time to analyze the devices and implement necessary patches to ensure their security.

The constant use of these devices in healthcare settings highlights the importance of finding a balance between security and functionality in order to safeguard sensitive patient data and uphold the integrity of the healthcare system.

Devices’ size and continuous connection result in insufficient battery support

Another challenge in the realm of IoT devices is related to their powering. Many of these devices use batteries and their compact size restricts the capacity for large, durable batteries. They need to be constantly connected to transmit data, which continually drains power.

These devices’ limited power and memory make it difficult to incorporate encryption, continuous software updates, and authentication protocols that can protect sensitive patient information from hackers.

Durability of IoT medical devices poses a security risk

Additionally, IoT medical devices are engineered to have a long lifespan. Their durability can pose a security risk. Once a vendor ceases production or stops releasing updates for these devices, hospitals may continue to rely on outdated technology, making them vulnerable to cyberattacks.

Hospitals must play a role in safeguarding their IoT device systems

Securing healthcare IoT devices can be a complex task, but it is essential to implement a variety of solutions to guarantee their security.

Part of this responsibility lies on the healthcare institutions themselves. Hospitals must ensure regular software updates, avoid default settings, and provide comprehensive training to staff members. Healthcare providers must implement unique and multilayered login structures for every device, such as two-step logins, hard-coded passwords, firewalls, and fingerprint checks to ensure that patient information is securely stored.

Leading players’ solutions increase devices’ resilience to breaches

Advanced and complex security solutions

Prominent vendors, such as Medigate, Medcrypt, and Cynerio, provide advanced platforms designed to assist healthcare organizations in safeguarding their networks and connected medical devices.

These security vendors offer complex security solutions, including real-time threat detection, device monitoring, network activity visibility to medical device manufacturers, and vulnerability management solutions to enable healthcare providers to effectively identify and mitigate potential risks associated with their connected medical devices.

Detection and recovery plan

Cybersecurity providers are generally vigilant in offering detection and recovery services to safeguard medical assets and systems around the clock. In the event of a security breach, they must be able to swiftly implement response and recovery plans to mitigate the impact. With a focus on healthcare, they must be able to identify issues efficiently without overwhelming users with excessive information. They need to aim at taking instant action to restore normalcy as quickly as possible.

Network segmentation

Another important solution players should provide is network segmentation, which involves dividing devices into separate, private wireless networks to protect data in the event of a cyberattack. Firewalls and multi-factor authentication can achieve this. By segmenting the network into distinct zones, healthcare providers can isolate medical devices from other parts of the network, reducing the risk of a cyberattack spreading across the entire network. This segmentation also allows for more granular control over medical devices, limiting the potential for unauthorized access or tampering.

Modern network segmentation for medical devices now relies on technologies such as virtual LANs and subnets to keep up with advanced cyber threats. For instance, Cisco Systems, a multinational technology conglomerate, offers medical device security solutions whose key aspect is network segmentation. Cisco also provides specialized monitoring and analytics tools to assist healthcare organizations in detecting and responding to security incidents in real time. These tools can identify abnormal behavior on the network, alerting security teams to potential threats before they can cause harm.

AI technology and machine learning

IoT device security providers, such as IBM Corporation, Cylera, CyberMDX, Sternum, ClearDATA, and Palo Alto Networks, place emphasis on conducting comprehensive risk assessments during software validation to guarantee devices’ security. In the event of new cyberattacks, these providers inform stakeholders and offer solutions, such as security updates. They have integrated programs that utilize AI technology and machine learning to proactively manage risks and stay ahead of cybersecurity threats.

Security vendors contribute to IoT device safety protocols transformation

The cybersecurity industry is currently experiencing a surge of new companies that are transforming security protocols. Armis, a leading US-based asset intelligence cybersecurity company and provider of agentless device security solutions, is spearheading this movement.

Notably, Medtronic and Zimmer Biomet have incorporated Armis’ security platform into their products, such as insulin pumps and orthopedic devices. Armis offers the Armis Centrix platform, powered by the Armis AI-driven Asset Intelligence Engine. The platform has the capability to detect breaches, run routine security scans or updates, maintain asset visibility, identify blind spots, optimize resource allocation, and perform essential maintenance. Armis’ solutions encompass advanced threat intelligence and machine learning features, enabling the system to adapt to new and emerging threats. This proactive cybersecurity approach is essential in the healthcare sector, where any disruption or compromising of medical devices could have severe repercussions.

Collaboration is key to effectively managing cyberattacks

Collaborations between medical device manufacturers and cybersecurity vendors to combat IoT medical device hacking have great potential. It also facilitates the sharing of threat intelligence and best practices, enabling vendors and manufacturers to proactively address emerging threats and vulnerabilities. Their collaborative efforts center on safeguarding critical devices from cyber risks by implementing protective measures for both the devices and the data they collect.

Philips partnered with CyberMDX to create a vendor-neutral cybersecurity service

In November 2020, Philips, a prominent player in healthcare technology, partnered with CyberMDX, a cybersecurity expert specializing in medical devices. This partnership focused on enhancing the security of connected medical devices and systems, essential for protecting patient data and for the smooth operation of healthcare facilities.

Drawing from Philips’ industry expertise and CyberMDX’s cybersecurity solutions, together they provide vendor-neutral options to protect IoT medical devices. They focus on managing connected devices in hospital settings, whether they are managed or unmanaged, by utilizing a combination of risk assessment, detection, threat intelligence, and prevention capabilities in the constantly evolving healthcare technology landscape.

Medcrypt collaborated with NetRise to address cybersecurity issues

In August 2023, Medcrypt, a US-based proactive cybersecurity provider, partnered with NetRise, another US-based cybersecurity company. By combining Medcrypt’s experience in identifying and managing vulnerabilities with NetRise’s ability to develop Mobile Device Management software featuring a Software Bill of Materials (SBOM) for embedded devices and firmware, medical device manufacturers now have access to a comprehensive solution to protect their devices from potential cyber threats throughout their lifecycle.

Medcrypt integrated NetRise’s SBOM generation capabilities into the Helm tool, enabling continuous integration, analysis, and transparency of the ever-changing state of medical device software. This integration facilitates the proactive identification and mitigation of the most exploitable vulnerabilities, extending support for SBOMs across the entire lifecycle of medical devices. The resulting solution empowers medical device manufacturers to create, ingest, enhance, manage, and monitor SBOMs, providing invaluable insights into the vulnerabilities present in their embedded devices and firmware. This collaboration represents a significant advancement in bolstering cybersecurity measures within the healthcare industry.

The industry is moving towards Trojan-free devices to safeguard against cyberattacks

Among the various cybersecurity threats faced by IoT medical devices, hardware Trojans are emerging as a grave concern. Hardware Trojans involve the deliberate manipulation of an integrated circuit or electronic device to compromise its security features or functionality.

Hardware Trojans are typically small in size, consist of only a few gates, and alter the device chip’s functionality. Due to their small size, hardware Trojans are challenging to detect using traditional offline methods such as side-channel analysis or digital systems testing. As a result, the healthcare industry is increasingly prioritizing the development of Trojan-free medical devices to enhance the security of IoT medical devices.

Unlike other medical devices, Trojan-free devices are highly secure and challenging to breach. Attackers would need a high level of expertise to understand the device’s design blueprint through reverse engineering and then create a manipulation that can only be triggered under specific conditions.

Moreover, the development of Trojan-free medical devices presents a unique opportunity for manufacturers to drive innovation, improve patient care, advance cybersecurity solutions, and shape regulatory standards.

One example of a Trojan-free medical device is the Philips IntelliVue patient monitor, which tracks patients’ vital signs and provide real-time data. This device works with advanced network security measures, including firewalls, encryption, and intrusion detection/prevention systems, to safeguard against unauthorized access and malware infiltration. Its cybersecurity features are specifically designed to protect against potential threats such as unauthorized access and data breaches.

Boston Scientific’s S-ICD implantable cardioverter-defibrillator is another Trojan-free medical device. It treats patients at risk of sudden cardiac arrest by delivering an electric shock to restore normal heart rhythm. This device employs encryption to secure communication between the device and the programmer and authentication protocols to ensure that only authorized healthcare professionals can access and control it.

EOS Perspective

IoT has transformed numerous industries, with healthcare being no exception. In the realm of healthcare, IoT medical devices utilized in virtual wards, such as remote monitoring devices and wearable sensors, are susceptible to cyberattacks. These attacks can result in unauthorized access, data tampering, and disruption of patient care. Detecting and responding to cyber threats targeting medical devices is crucial.

To combat these threats, security vendors employed prevention systems, anomaly detection algorithms, and advanced analytics to identify potential cyberattacks and abnormal device behavior. Implementing robust incident response plans, conducting simulated exercises, and utilizing strong device security measures is imperative to safeguard against device-level cyber risks.

The field of cybersecurity in healthcare is intricate and constantly evolving. Addressing cybersecurity risks necessitates a comprehensive approach that encompasses technology, policies, regulations, and education. Continuous collaboration, vigilance, and adaptation to emerging threats are essential to ensure the security and safety of medical devices in the future.

Moreover, healthcare facilities must prioritize the implementation of robust device security risk management practices. This involves establishing standard protocols, automating device isolation, utilizing asset intelligence to minimize security breaches, and ensuring compliance with regulatory frameworks such as HIPAA, FDA, ISO 13485, and HITRUST when acquiring and managing connected medical devices.

In addition, healthcare facilities must provide comprehensive training to professionals who work with these devices on cybersecurity best practices and identifying potential security threats.

Collaboration between healthcare providers, device manufacturers, cybersecurity experts, and regulatory bodies is essential for enhancing the security of medical IoT devices. By sharing knowledge, resources, and best practices, stakeholders can collectively address vulnerabilities and safeguard healthcare systems.

Their collaborative efforts facilitate the adoption of SBOM formats, threat modeling processes, Secure Product Development Framework, encryption technologies, AI-based anomaly detection, regulatory frameworks, and secure hardware modules. This approach ensures a more secure environment for medical IoT devices and ultimately protects patient data and healthcare systems from potential cyber threats.

Innovations such as blockchain technology, biometric authentication, predictive analytics, regular patching or updates, and Trojan-free medical devices offer promising opportunities to enhance security measures in the healthcare sector. Trojan-free medical devices, in particular, show great potential in safeguarding patient data, ensuring device integrity, and maintaining the trustworthiness of healthcare technology. This not only improves device reliability but also reduces downtime, benefiting both patients and healthcare providers. This is likely the direction the industry will take in the long run.

By prioritizing proactive cybersecurity measures and compliance with regulations, healthcare security providers can offer potential solutions to enhance the security and integrity of medical devices and the data they handle.

Charting the RegTech Journey – Navigating Consolidation as the Next Vital Phase by EOS Intelligence
by EOS Intelligence EOS Intelligence No Comments

Charting the RegTech Journey: Navigating Consolidation

RegTech, short for regulatory technology and often categorized as a subset of fintech, emerged in 2015. The RegTech industry was fragmented, with numerous small players targeting specific niches within the regulatory compliance landscape. However, the recent trend towards consolidation is reshaping the sector. Larger RegTech firms are increasingly acquiring smaller players to expand their offerings and solidify their market positions.

RegTech comprises powerful tools that leverage advanced technologies such as artificial intelligence (AI), automated machine learning (AML), and big data analytics. These technologies streamline regulatory compliance processes, addressing challenges from technology-driven economies, largely through automation. Automation plays a significant role in reassuring regulatory compliance professionals about the effectiveness and efficiency of RegTech solutions.

According to a 2023 report by Corlytics, a Dublin-based regulatory risk intelligence firm, regulatory penalties associated with legal and regulatory enforcement in the financial sector exceeded US$10.5 billion globally. This underscores the escalating pressure on financial institutions to comply with regulations, prompting them to turn to innovative technological solutions. RegTech has emerged as a promising avenue for organizations within the fintech ecosystem to efficiently navigate complex regulatory landscapes while reducing cost and time and improving compliance effectiveness.

Market landscape transformation through investments and strategic acquisitions

Investors increasingly recognize RegTech’s potential, and it remains a bright spot within the fintech ecosystem. Data from UK-based financial market platform Dealogic shows 116 global RegTech deals in 2023 with a total value of more than US$13.5 billion, demonstrating significant investment activity in the sector. Last year witnessed notable acquisitions across various markets, with larger financial services corporations and RegTech vendors acquiring smaller players to strengthen their market position through consolidation.

Key transactions, such as the acquisition of Adenza by Nasdaq for US$10.5 billion in 2023 and Finellix by Stellex Capital for US$176 million in 2022, underline the strategic importance of RegTech solutions for both financial and technology companies.

These developments reflect a broad strategic move to address the escalating compliance costs faced by banks and brokerages in the wake of regulatory reforms such as the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (simply known as the Dodd-Frank Act). The Dodd-Frank Act, introduced in the USA in 2010 following the 2007–2008 financial crisis, has had a profound impact on the global financial sector. The Act has prompted financial institutions globally to significantly improve their regulatory reporting systems and processes, leading to more extensive adoption of technology solutions. Dodd-Frank and other stringent regulatory measures have significantly increased compliance costs for financial institutions and companies operating in various sectors.

Larger financial services firms and RegTech companies are consolidating to integrate complementary financial solutions and expand their operations. In one such development, US-based automated RegTech player CUBE acquired UK-based counterpart The Hub Technology in 2023 to further boost their automated regulatory intelligence (ARI) abilities to reduce compliance risk and cost.

Consolidation within the RegTech sector aims to empower larger entities to effectively tackle challenges related to anti-financial crime measures, cross-selling opportunities, and regulatory compliance services, primarily among banking and brokerage clients. This strategy aims to diversify revenue streams, broaden market reach, and increase the serviceable market.

Simultaneously, M&A offers small and mid-size RegTech companies a strategic avenue to enhance capabilities, achieve accelerated growth, better competitive market positioning, and maximize value. While acquisitions often lead to integration within the larger corporate structure, there is still room for acquired smaller RegTech companies to maintain a level of independence.

In 2023, Corlytics acquired the UK-based RegTech firm Clausematch to integrate its capabilities into a comprehensive platform for managing the regulatory risk value chain for tier-1 clients. Despite the acquisition, Clausematch maintains its independence and is a strategic partner to Corlytics. It continues to serve existing clients while also extending its services to Corlytics tier-1 clients, including 14 of the top 50 global banks. This autonomy can be instrumental in fostering partnerships that are essential for scaling up and achieving sustainable growth in the ever-changing fintech regulatory ecosystem that demands agility and continuous innovation.

The appeal of RegTech’s one-stop-shop model

The concept of a one-stop shop model in the RegTech industry, facilitated by consolidation, appeals to businesses seeking streamlined and comprehensive compliance solutions. In the evolving financial market landscape, clients are increasingly preferring to consolidate their RegTech solutions under a single provider rather than engaging with multiple vendors. This demand stems from the desire for streamlined processes, reduced administrative burden, cost savings, and seamless integration of services.

RegTech companies can meet this demand and improve the overall customer experience by offering comprehensive end-to-end solutions and value-added services. In 2023, Muinmos, a Denmark-based RegTech company, saw substantial revenue growth as more clients flocked to the firm. This surge was attributed to Muinmos’ comprehensive platform, which manages the entire onboarding process, spanning from KYC/AML procedures to risk assessments and regulatory classification.

Through strategic acquisitions of smaller RegTech firms with specialized solutions, RegTech solution providers can further enhance their offerings, capitalizing on the trend for integrated solutions and establishing a competitive edge in the market.

Partnerships with smaller firms provide larger companies in the RegTech sector with advantages such as accelerated time-to-market and the opportunity to serve as a testing ground, paving the way for potential future acquisitions.

RegTech startups joining forces

Many RegTech startups are partnering to provide a broader range of regulatory solutions to their clients by enhancing their platforms and adding compatible services from other partners. This forms a robust entity with expanded capabilities to compete with established players.

In November 2023, Flagright, a German-based startup specializing in AML compliance and fraud prevention, formed a strategic alliance with Regtank Technology, a Singapore-based RegTech services provider. This partnership underscores their joint commitment to developing an advanced transaction monitoring solution for fintech companies using AI/ML algorithms. Additionally, these partnerships are likely to help startups reach more customers across various geographies, solving risk and compliance challenges for more businesses.

The double-edged sword of consolidation

For existing and emerging RegTech companies, consolidation presents a double-edged sword. As larger players consolidate and dominate the market, there may be fewer opportunities for investment in smaller, emerging RegTech startups. Investors may perceive greater risk in backing smaller players when larger, more established firms offer similar or more comprehensive solutions. This could lead to a concentration of investment in a few key players, potentially stifling innovation and diversity in the market.

Consolidation impact on the RegTech investment landscape

With fewer startups and a more prominent role for established players, the overall number of investment opportunities in RegTech may slow down in the short term. This could lead to a shift in focus from rapid innovation to the successful integration of acquired technologies as larger players seek to leverage their expanded capabilities and market presence.

Challenges faced by small firms and emerging startups

Consolidation within the RegTech sector could heighten entry barriers for new and smaller firms. Small companies are likely to face resource constraints compared to their larger counterparts. They may struggle to match the scale of investment, R&D capabilities, and market reach of consolidated firms, potentially limiting their ability to innovate and expand their market reach.

Opportunity for small vendors due to consolidation

Consolidation could create gaps in the market for specialized RegTech solutions catering to unaddressed regulatory needs within the RegTech industry. Consolidation efforts in the RegTech sector mainly target large tier-1 clients, including large banks and other financial institutions. However, there are potential gaps and opportunities in smaller businesses across non-financial verticals that require tailored regulatory solutions. This would likely prompt smaller companies to carve out niche areas of specialization within the evolving RegTech landscape.

Specializing in particular regulatory domains, industries, or technological niches allows smaller firms to distinguish themselves as providers of specialized solutions. This makes them appealing targets for acquisition or partnerships by larger players, driven by the ongoing consolidation trends in the RegTech sector.

EOS Perspective

Traditionally, many RegTech companies evolved as single-point solutions for specific regulations. The market is witnessing a shift away from multi-point solutions that address specific issues and moving towards modular solutions that offer flexibility and can be reconfigured to address diverse problems and industry verticals. This shift is likely to drive further consolidation as regulated entities seek mature, cost-effective solutions tailored to their needs.

Conventionally, RegTech solutions have primarily targeted large enterprises with significant budgets. However, we are witnessing a notable shift, as small RegTech companies are now offering affordable compliance solutions tailored to small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) as well. This shift is driven by the recognition of unique regulatory challenges faced by different sectors, such as healthcare, insurance, and energy. This recognition prompts small RegTech players to tap into opportunities arising from the growing demand for industry-specific RegTech solutions. This trend reflects a broader movement within the RegTech industry towards democratizing access to compliance tools and addressing the specific needs of diverse business sectors.

With venture funding slowing down due to the economic downturn, a rise in M&A activities is anticipated in the coming years. Due to the time-consuming nature of decision-making around procuring RegTech solutions by regulated entities, major RegTech players are expected to focus on developing and offering sticky RegTech solutions to ensure stable and recurring revenue growth. Consequently, this trend is likely to drive further consolidation within the large RegTech sector, as evidenced by Corolytics’ acquisition of ING SparQ RegTech and Clausematch in 2023, followed by a substantial investment from Verdane, an investment firm, in April 2024. This investment is poised to accelerate Corlytics’ M&A activity, signaling a shift towards the emergence of technology partners that provide unified platforms by integrating solutions from multiple firms through consolidation.

Pet Wearables – Are Companies Barking up the Right Technology by EOS Intelligence
by EOS Intelligence EOS Intelligence No Comments

Pet Wearables – Are Companies Barking Up the Right Technology?

430views

As the human wearables market begins to mature, a lot of interest and developments are also happening in the pet wearables space. An increasing number of pet owners becoming more technologically savvy has fueled product innovations in this segment, which traditionally was limited to GPS tracking. While location tracking continues to be the largest piece of the pie, other solutions, such as health monitoring devices, have been gaining prominence. However, this segment is still in its infancy and is toying with several technologies, such as biometrics, radar, and acoustic technology, to develop functional, accurate, and price-effective devices.

The last decade has witnessed exponential growth and advancements in human wearables. However, recent years have also seen the trend of wearables permeating the pet market. With upcoming technological advancements, the industry is expected to witness double-digit growth over the next six years and expand into new territories.

Read our related Perspective

Poop to Pills: Is FMT the Future of Veterinary Medicine?

ID tracking is the largest category, health monitoring is growing the fastest

The pet wearables market is primarily bifurcated into four applications: ID tracking, behavior control, safety, and health monitoring. At the moment, the largest category within the market is ID tracking solutions, which comprise GPS—and RFID-based trackers that help identify and locate pets. One of the leading players in this space is US-based Tractive, which provides a GPS collar that allows pet owners to know the exact location of their pets at all times.

The fastest-growing category is health monitoring. This segment encompasses devices that monitor a pet’s vitals and general health and raise an alarm in case of any irregularities. Growing pet obesity cases have resulted in pet owners choosing health monitoring devices for their pets. A popular product in this space is the PetPace Smart Collar by US-based pet wearable company, PetPace, which tracks physiological metrics such as pulse, respiration, temperature, heart rate variability (HRV), activity level, and posture. Along with GPS tracking and emergency alerts, it helps in early symptom detection and disease management.

The behavior control segment, which is still relatively small, covers products that help teach pets appropriate behavior, such as bark collars, which deter dogs from barking continuously. An innovative and popular product in this category includes the PetSafe Treat & Train Remote Reward Dog Trainer by US-based pet-tech company PetSafe. The product allows pet owners to dispense treats remotely through an electronic trainer to induce calm behavior in case of distracting situations, as well as allows owners to reward their pets in case of good behavior.

The smallest category is safety, which is largely an extension of ID tracking and comprises pet cameras that capture a pet’s movement. Mr. Petcam is a US-based company that provides collar-mounted HD video cameras for dogs or cats, allowing pet owners to see what their pets see in the yard, at home, or during walks.

Pet Wearables – Are Companies Barking up the Right Technology by EOS Intelligence

Pet Wearables – Are Companies Barking Up the Right Technology? by EOS Intelligence

The industry is undergoing both organic and inorganic growth

Pet adoption increased significantly during the COVID-19 pandemic as people were confined to their homes and lacked social and emotional connection. As per the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, one in five Americans purchased or adopted a pet during COVID-19.

Many of these pet owners are adept in technology and spend vast sums of money on their pets. As pets are increasingly considered family members and with growing concerns for their health and well-being, pet wearables are experiencing a surge in popularity. The success of wearable technology for humans further fuels this trend. Moreover, increasing costs of veterinary services and treatments have propelled pet owners to invest in health and prevention-based wearables. Therefore, the industry is expected to grow significantly, especially in Europe and North America, in the coming years.

However, that being said, the industry is in its nascence and is highly fragmented at the moment. There is a large number of players fueled by several start-ups and new entrants. The industry is seeing a surge in acquisitions as players in the pet care and tech space are looking to expand their offerings to include pet wearables. Moreover, growing interest from venture capital firms is also resulting in large investments in companies showing promise in this space.

One of the leading players in the pet market, Mars Petcare, launched Companion Fund in 2018 and Companion Fund II in October 2023. The US$100 million and US$300 million venture capital funds, respectively, have been created to invest in start-ups in the pet care space, including pet wearables. Earlier, in 2016, Mars Petcare acquired the Whistle pet monitor and GPS tracker, similar to a Fitbit for dogs, for about US$117 million. This provided Mars Petcare an entry into the pet wearables space.

Several other players in the technology space have also acquired companies to expand their business to cover pet wearables. In 2019, Florida-based IoT company Smart Tracking Technologies acquired Link AKC for an undisclosed amount. This wearable pet technology company developed GPS-enabled dog collars and won the Best Innovation award at CES 2017 in the wearable technology category.

In April 2023, Ultrack, a leading global GPS tracking solutions provider, signed a contractual agreement to acquire and market Supreme Product’s wearable GPS-based Pet Tracker. The device is expected to have multiple features, such as health monitoring, behavior modification, predictive analytics, social media integration, and virtual fences.

Similarly, in May 2023, Datamars, a global data solutions company, acquired Kippy, an Italy-based GPS tracking and activity monitoring solution provider. Kippy collar’s main features include GPS tracking, customized activity monitoring and analysis, reminders and access to vet records, temperature alerts, tone and vibration training controls, a built-in flashlight, and the ability to create safe places for the pet.

While several companies are adopting the inorganic growth strategy, there is also a lot of venture capital interest, especially in ID tracking, which is the largest product category and acts as an entry point device for many customers in the pet wearables space. In 2021, Austria-based leading pet tracking company Tractive raised US$35 million Series A round (led by Guidepost Growth Equity) to expand its offerings in the USA. Similarly, in 2021, Fi, a US-based pet wearable start-up, received US$30 million in Series B funding (following a Series A funding of US$ 7 million in 2019) for its smart pet collars to expand its footprint across the USA.

Pet wearables companies seek the right tech for pet health monitoring

While most technologies used in pet wearables are fairly similar to those used in human wearables (such as GPS), one of the key differentiators is the effectiveness of biometric sensors for health monitoring. Biometric sensors are widely used in human wearables, although given the fur presence in animals, they are somewhat ineffective in the case of pets. Thus, pet wearables depend on other contactless sensors such as radar and acoustic. However, these have their own functional and developmental challenges.

Among these, acoustic sensors are some of the oldest and are used by one of the market leaders, PetPace. Acoustic technology uses sound waves to monitor a pet’s heart rate, heart rate variability (HRV), and respiratory rate. Players such as PetPace and Inupathy use this technology in their smart collars. Moreover, in 2020, the Bioengineering Department at Imperial College also developed wearable technology for sniffer dogs based on acoustic sensors.

While this technology is fairly widely used for clinically monitoring health for both humans and pets, there are certain challenges when it is translated into wearables for pets. Given external factors, such as background noise and motion artifacts, the PetPace collar is said to have only 53% heart rate detection sensitivity (i.e., in 53% of the cases, the standard deviation from measurements by PetPace and ECG was within 10%) based on a study conducted in 2020. However, based on another 2017 study, the device’s pulse monitoring accuracy levels can be much higher at 94.3%.

That being said, Tokyo-based Inupathy also uses acoustic sensors to capture a dog’s heart rate and HRV and displays colors and patterns on its pet collar to depict emotional state and heartbeat ranges. For instance, the calmest state is depicted with deep blue, whereas the most excited state is bright red. While the company claims to have 90% accuracy when compared with ECG monitors, the collar is marketed as a device to broadly understand the mental and physical state of the pet instead of accurately monitoring and projecting heart rate readings.

Thus, while acoustic technology can be used in pet wearables, it has limitations, especially regarding accuracy. With the PetPace collar being priced at about US$150 (with a monthly subscription of US$15) and Inupathy at US$200, the customer must be able to find value in the readings. One of the initial companies using acoustic sensors, Voyce, went out of business in 2016 due to slower-than-expected acceptability.

Acoustic sensors-based solutions by themselves may not be a sound product offering, however, when clubbed with other technologies and solutions, they can offer a wholesome solution to the pet owner. This can be seen in the case of PetPace Smart Collar, which, along with acoustic-based health monitoring, has additional offerings such as thermometers for temperature detection, 6-D accelerometers for activity, calories, and posture calculation, and GPS for location tracking.

A more promising and upcoming technology for health monitoring in pets is radar technology. The technology uses radio waves to enable continuous and contactless heart and respiration rate monitoring. While it is relatively new, it is expected to have better accuracy when compared with acoustic sensors. Two companies, France-based Invoxia, and Taiwan-based ITRI, launched smart collars with radar technology in 2022. Invoxia’s smart collar is priced competitively at US$99 (with a monthly subscription of US$13). It uses embedded artificial intelligence and miniaturized radar sensors to track a dog’s health. In addition, it monitors a dog’s daily activity, such as walking, running, scratching, eating or drinking, barking, and resting. The device has an accuracy of 98% for heart rate detection.

Similarly, ITRI also launched its smart wearable device, iPetWear, in 2022. The device uses contactless micro-physiological radar sensing technology to monitor a pet’s health. The sensor can monitor a pet’s heart rate, respiratory rate, sleep cycle, and activity levels through the detection of pulse and chest motion through its lower-power Doppler radar technology. The device claims to have an error rate of under 10% for heart and respiration rate and under 5% for activity monitoring. The device is priced at US$80.

Given the improved accuracies and competitive pricing of these products, it is safe to say that radar technology-based sensors can disrupt pet health monitoring wearables. However, this technology is difficult to develop, and at the moment, only a limited number of companies have managed to commercialize it.

Companies are also exploring ways to make biometric sensors effective for pets, even though furry pets present a challenge for such sensors. This is seen in the case of Invoxia, which had previously launched the radar-based Smart Collar. At CES 2024, Invoxia launched another pet wearable device, the Invoxia Minitailz Smart Pet Tracker. The tracker uses advanced miniaturized biometric sensors along with AI to track respiratory and heart vitals and detect anomalies in the behavior of both dogs and cats. In addition, it tracks a pet’s location and daily activities and can differentiate between types of movement. It also claims to be the first pet collar in the market to detect atrial fibrillation (AFib). The device also seems to have high accuracy (similar to radar technology) as it claims to have 97-99% accuracy rates for monitoring respiratory and heart vitals. The product, priced at US$99 with a monthly subscription cost of US$8.30, is relatively new in the market, and its effectiveness is yet to be established.

If Invoxia Minitailz Smart Pet Tracker is successful and delivers on its promise (with regard to accuracy and functionality), several other players will likely also explore biometric sensors for pet health monitoring.

Other technologies, such as LiDAR and infrared, are also being explored as potential alternatives. However, there are not many commercially successful solutions based on them yet.

Potential risk of data breach is one of the biggest threats to pet wearables

Given the expanding scope of all these technologies, the pet wearable market is booming. However, it comes with its own set of challenges. While companies claim to have high accuracy rates, no FDA approvals are required for pet wearables at the moment. Thus, there is no way to verify the actual effectiveness of these devices. Moreover, since they deal with critical health conditions, a missed reading or a misdiagnosis can have dire consequences. Pet owners can also not consider these devices to be a replacement for their vet visits at large, and the devices can only act as information gatherers that can help vets make quicker diagnoses.

The industry is also facing a significant obstacle in the form of substandard battery technology. Given the number of features on each device (such as GPS tracking, health monitoring, two-way communication, etc.), its continuous and real-time work requirement, and the limited lifespan of lithium-ion batteries, companies have difficulty providing sufficient battery life for their devices. In several cases, pet owners find that the battery gets discharged sooner than they can recharge it. Therefore, the device loses its purpose since it is meant to provide continuous real-time data to be effective. To mitigate this, companies are looking into other battery options, such as lead acid (less efficient than lithium-ion) and silicon carbide (a more expensive option).

Another issue with these devices is the potential risk of data breaches. Wearables collect large amounts of data about pets and pet owners. In a 2019 study by Bristol University, pet wearable devices collected four times more data about the pet owner than about the pet itself. If this data is not properly secured, it could result in data leaks and cyberattacks and put the owner at risk.

EOS Perspective

With pet ownership increasing, the market for pet wearables will undoubtedly grow. Moreover, as human wearables continue to permeate our daily lives, it is natural that pet owners are looking for a similar advanced level of monitoring for their beloved companions.

The market, which started with single functionality tracking devices, is now moving towards more complex and technologically advanced solutions. While tracking and GPS-based devices continue to form a significant portion of the market at the moment, several leading players in the space (such as Tractive) are now integrating other functionalities with their location-tracking offerings.

Thus, the market is expected to move towards multi-functional solutions that offer basic features such as tracking along with advanced features such as activity and health monitoring. Also, within health monitoring, offerings will continue to differ based on complexity. For instance, some devices offer insights only into weight and temperature changes, while more advanced devices offer heart and pulse rate monitoring. As seen in the case of human wearables, the market is likely to move towards the latter as continuous advanced health monitoring becomes a standard way of managing well-being for both humans and pets.

Given the industry’s nascence, fragmented market, lack of big established brands, and low brand loyalty, the products’ key differentiating factors are likely to remain competitive pricing, advanced offerings, and effective technology.

For this, it becomes essential for companies to stay ahead of the curve and to explore possible technologies, beyond what is effective in human wearables. Therefore, companies that are investing in exploring suitable technologies, such as radar and biometrics, for advanced features, such as heart rate monitoring, are likely to emerge as market leaders in the long run.

Moreover, the pet wearables market is likely to also benefit from integration with pet insurance in the future. Both industries have synergies as the insurance sector can gain from health-based data derived from pet wearables. On the other hand, increasing demand for pet insurance is expected to provide a push to the pet wearables market, as pet owners who track and monitor their pet’s health can negotiate better and more competitive insurance rates.

Undoubtedly, the industry is poised for steady and strong growth. The market will likely consolidate, while players offering technologically advanced wearables focused on health monitoring and priced at around US$100-150 will emerge as leaders.

Denmark – A Trailblazer in Digital Health Innovation by EOS Intelligence
by EOS Intelligence EOS Intelligence 4 Comments

Denmark – A Trailblazer in Digital Health Innovation

546views

The COVID-19 pandemic has spurred the need to embrace new digital tools and technologies within the healthcare sector. There has been a significant increase in the use of technology to provide care, resulting in improved health outcomes. In Europe, Denmark has made significant progress and is at the forefront of the digital health transformation with a 99% digitalization rate. Over the last few years, Denmark has strived to digitalize further its healthcare infrastructure, testing and leveraging technologies such as AI and robotics to implement them at full scale across the country. In this transformation, the Danish digital health system can be a source of valuable lessons, uncovering various opportunities it presents for health tech companies.

Demark’s digital health: Harnessing power from a robust public infrastructure

Denmark’s healthcare system is among the most expensive worldwide, with 10% of GDP allotted for healthcare expenditures and 90% publicly funded through taxes. The health infrastructure is highly digitalized, with almost 99% of healthcare communication done electronically.

The national e-health portal, Sundhed.dk, launched in 2003, plays a key role in Denmark’s digitalization, offering a comprehensive platform catering to both healthcare professionals and citizens alike. Sundhed.dk provides safe and secure access to an individual’s personal health records (from hospitals), medication information, vaccinations, laboratory results, appointments, and referrals. The portal is user-friendly and is regarded as one of the superior models for public healthcare information exchange worldwide.

Over the last 20 years, the Danish government has supported and invested in various digital health initiatives, rolled out several IT services, and strengthened its digital healthcare infrastructure. In 2007, the country introduced E-record, through which individuals can access their medical information from EHR systems using the Sundhed.dk portal. The government also launched Shared Medication Record, which has records of patients’ prescriptions, details of the doctor who prescribed the medicines, and information pertaining to where the medications were picked from. During the COVID-19 pandemic, the “My Doctor” app was introduced to facilitate video consultations between GPs and patients. These digital initiatives contribute to improved care coordination and increase the patient’s trust in the system.

Denmark – A Trailblazer in Digital Health Innovation by EOS Intelligence

Denmark – A Trailblazer in Digital Health Innovation by EOS Intelligence

Unraveling the blueprint: Denmark’s digital health success story

Well-formulated digital health strategies address the needs of patients and healthcare workers

Many countries develop digital health strategies, which are frequently focused solely on technical aspects, steering away from addressing the actual needs of patients and healthcare professionals. Moreover, these policies often function as plain vision documents with no clear description of action plans or the roles and responsibilities of various stakeholders.

In contrast, Denmark’s digital health strategy is well-formulated and primarily focused on addressing the needs of patients and healthcare workers. It provides a clear vision of how digital technology can help meet their needs. In addition, the strategies highlight the importance of cross-sectoral collaboration, detailing focus areas and specific initiatives that must be jointly executed. For instance, it clearly mentions how the health and education sectors should work together to promote digital health literacy.

Denmark’s well-crafted digital health policies are a cornerstone of its successful digital health transformation. Since 1999, the country has been updating these strategies every four years, ensuring ongoing review and modernization of its digital health infrastructure.

Governance models aid in the speedy integration and implementation of digital healthcare tools

Denmark follows a regional governance model instead of the top-down approach, controlled by the state (national) government. The states and municipalities are responsible for developing and implementing their own health IT solutions in alignment with the national strategy.

Further, the government has established several steering groups to aid in implementing and disseminating digital health initiatives for rapid digital uptake. For instance, Connected Digital Health in Denmark, a cross-governmental organization, manages, coordinates, and ensures the implementation of various action plans mentioned in the national digital health strategies.

In addition, the government also regularly engages in public-private partnerships to boost its digital capabilities. The country’s strong governance is considered one of the critical success factors for the digital health transition.

Common IT standards help in effective healthcare data exchange

Many countries have deployed digital health technologies; however, integration remains sparse, resulting in a fragmented digital landscape. Integrating patient information siloed across multiple healthcare segments is crucial for establishing a high-quality digital health infrastructure. The adoption of common IT standards helps facilitate this data exchange and integration.

Denmark has been using these standards since 1990 for electronic health data communication as well as improving workflows between public hospitals, general practitioners, private healthcare entities, specialists, laboratories, and home care services. The early development of these standards significantly increased electronic communication within the healthcare sector, contributing to the high level of digitalization of the Danish healthcare sector.

Strict testing protocols ensure digital health tools are user-friendly

The user-friendliness of digital technologies is considered one of the major factors for early e-health adoption. Denmark undertakes several initiatives to ensure that digital health tools and technologies are user-friendly and easy to use. For instance, the country collects feedback from healthcare stakeholders about their experience with various digital health solutions, checks if they are user-friendly, and uses the input received to develop new solutions.

The country has also implemented strict testing protocols for telehealth solutions by evaluating their performance on mobile devices and testing the products with a range of end users, including the elderly and people with disabilities.

Government’s focus on educating and training healthcare stakeholders helps them to use digital tools effectively

Denmark educates and trains healthcare workers to use digital tools appropriately. According to a 2020 Deloitte report, nearly 76.8 % of Danish clinicians mentioned that they are well-trained and supported in using digital health tools and solutions.

Local governments and hospitals in Denmark collaborate with tech professionals to provide support, education, and training on using digital solutions such as EMRs, telemedicine platforms, and shared IT standards for healthcare data exchange. Digital health literacy of front-line healthcare workers is one of the core objectives of the country’s digital health strategy.

Unlocking opportunities: Denmark’s digital health sector for health tech companies

According to Statistics Denmark, the percentage of the Danish population aged 75 or above is expected to double from 7.8% in 2017 to 14.4% in 2047. In addition, the country faces a severe labor shortage, with projections suggesting that by 2035, Denmark might have a shortage of 14,500 healthcare workers. These factors are expected to put increased pressure on the Danish healthcare system.

In order to tackle these challenges, Denmark’s government continues to invest in advanced innovative technologies and digitalization strategies. In 2018, the country launched a digital health strategy titled “A Coherent and Trustworthy Health Network for All: 2018-2024”, aiming to modernize the healthcare infrastructure further. Under this initiative, the country aims to expand telemedicine solutions, increase virtual care visits, and automate the administrative and clinical workflows within the Danish healthcare system. This initiative is creating opportunities for startups and companies offering health tech solutions in the areas of telemedicine, video consultations, remote patient monitoring, hospital automation, and diagnostics.

Danish government seeks to expand telemedicine solutions for various segments of the patient population

Denmark has been using telemedicine services since 2012, beginning with home monitoring solutions for Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) patients. The country seeks to further expand the rollout of telemedicine solutions for patients with COPD, chronic diseases, heart failure, comorbid conditions, and pregnant women facing complications. In December 2023, the government of Denmark invested about US$72 million to expand telemedicine solutions for these patients, offer digital rehabilitation courses, and increase the number of virtual consultations through GPs.

Various governmental organizations in Denmark have been looking to partner with companies providing innovative remote monitoring and virtual care solutions to facilitate home treatment.

For instance, in 2021, in collaboration with the local government, Trifork, a Denmark-based digital health company, developed a telemedicine solution called Telma for severe COPD patients. The solution provides COPD patients with medication, measuring tools, and devices to track pulse and oxygen levels at home. The Telma app transmits this data in real time and facilitates communication between healthcare professionals and patients through video consultations, thus lessening the need for frequent hospital visits.

Similarly, in 2022, two Denmark-based health tech companies, Copenhagen Center for Health Technology (CACHET) and Cortrium, forged a research collaboration to develop a novel technology to monitor a patient’s heart rhythm remotely. This allows heart failure patients to receive prompt medical care without visiting a hospital.

The Danish government is also looking to provide telerehabilitation services amidst the rising mental health issues across the country. In 2021, the government established the Centre for Digital Psychiatry to develop, test, and implement several nationwide digital services. In March 2023, the Center initiated a research project with Monsenso, a Danish mobile health company, to provide personalized digital treatment for patients with depression.

A rise in telemedicine programs catering to various segments of the patient population is expected in the forthcoming years. This surge in demand fuels the growth of companies offering telehealth solutions nationwide.

AI presents several opportunities for innovation and collaboration within the healthcare segment

Denmark actively seeks to integrate AI into its healthcare system, especially in diagnostics, presenting numerous opportunities for AI-based health companies to thrive. The country has established research and innovation centers across the country focusing on AI for uses such as identifying at-risk stroke patients, helping radiologists interpret scans, and assisting in other diagnostics.

In 2021, Denmark established the Radiology AI Test Center (RAIT) to accelerate the development and implementation of medical AI applications in the country. Through RAIT, private companies can test and validate their AI-based technologies in Denmark. For example, in 2021, through the RAIT program, several Danish hospitals in Copenhagen partnered with US-based imaging AI startup Enlitic to evaluate an AI-based algorithm to read chest X-rays. Similarly, in 2023, RAIT partnered with Cerebriu, a Denmark-based health tech company, to use AI to improve MRI imaging of the brain.

Investments in advanced digital technologies modernize healthcare infrastructure

As Denmark endeavors to digitalize its hospitals, ample opportunities arise for companies specializing in robotics and mobile health to improve hospital and clinical workflows, among other areas.

Some steps have been taken to digitalize hospitals. For instance, the Centre for Clinical Robotics (CCR), a research and innovation center for healthcare robotic technology in Denmark, aims to leverage robotic technology for various hospital processes, such as food service, cleaning, medication dispensing, clinical sample collection, etc.

Another interesting instance is the pilot project between Systematic, a Denmark-based software company, and physicians at the Aalborg University Hospital. Systematic has developed a communication platform called Columna Flow Clinical Tasking, which facilitates direct communication among the physicians at the Aalborg Hospital. The solution offers a real-time overview of the patients, including their medical conditions and the workload of hospital clinicians on duty. This empowers physicians to prioritize patients and efficiently allocate tasks during peak hospital hours.

EOS Perspective

The Danish health system is poised for an even more profound digital transformation in the coming years, aiming to improve patient accessibility and convenience. Denmark’s healthcare market is already highly digitalized, which provides a robust foundation for further digital transformation and innovation.

Home care and telemedicine, health data interoperability, AI-based diagnosis, healthcare automation, personalized medicine, and preventative health are likely the key focus areas for the next phase of digital health transformation.

Further, the country is looking to elevate patient care through its super hospital program, which involves consolidating smaller hospitals into larger, higher-capacity units. The aim is to provide superior medical care at lower costs. Technology will play a key role in improving healthcare delivery and patient outcomes in these hospitals, with applications across logistics, clinical decision support tools, diagnostic tools management, and patient engagement, among other areas.

These initiatives can be expected to make the Danish health system even more robust. The system is expected to move from a doctor-centric to a patient-centric care model, where patients would be actively involved in taking care of their own health. The country’s meticulously crafted digital health strategies, well-established digital infrastructure, and technology-proficient population lay a solid foundation to usher in the next wave of innovation.

As Denmark persists in its commitment to build a healthcare system fit for the future, there are abundant opportunities for health tech companies to thrive and drive innovation within the Danish healthcare industry.

FemTech A Game-Changer in Womens Healthcare by EOS Intelligence
by EOS Intelligence EOS Intelligence No Comments

FemTech: A Game-Changer in Women’s Healthcare

Women’s healthcare is one of the most neglected and understudied fields in the healthcare sector. Despite substantial advances in medical sciences in recent years, there still exists a huge gap in the treatment of diseases that are specific to women. FemTech focuses on addressing some of these gaps and offers the potential to help tackle the longstanding issues of women’s health.

FemTech developed as an answer to inadequate healthcare for women

According to a 2018 article published in Our World in Data, a UK-based online scientific publication, human life expectancy has increased tremendously from 30 to 73 years during the last two centuries (1800–2018). But this leap has not been reflected in women’s life quality. A 2024 report published by the World Economic Forum and the McKinsey Health Institute indicated that women live 25% longer in poor health than men, although they typically outlive males.

FemTech, a group of technology-enabled solutions such as diagnostic tools, wearables, products, software, and services, aims to tackle women’s health issues, such as maternal, reproductive, menstrual, and sexual health, as well as menopause. An example is the UK-based Flo Health app that tracks ovulation and the menstrual cycle, offers customized health insights and tips, and a closed community for sharing concerns and queries. US-based Natural Cycles is another example. This application provides personalized insights based on each user’s menstrual cycle patterns. This novel approach to improving women’s health and well-being has been gaining more importance in recent years.

Several challenges slow down progress and widespread acceptance

While FemTech offers promising solutions to help diagnose and manage many health issues affecting women that were previously overlooked, several challenges are awaiting interested players.

One major bottleneck players face is the scarcity of investments. Many investors still consider FemTech a niche sector and shy away from investing compared to other healthcare fields. This situation is slightly improving, as the industry has seen an increase in investment in recent years. Data from Dealroom, an Amsterdam-based provider of data and insights on start-ups and tech ecosystems, indicated that the venture capital (VC) funding into FemTech startups reached US$2.1 billion in 2021, an all-time high.

Despite this increase in investment in FemTech, the total funding for this sector still trails other sectors, especially if it is female-led. The CEO of a leading US-based fertility tracker Mira, said in an interview with Forbes that though 70% of FemTech startups are female-founded, male-owned businesses tend to raise more capital.

Investors and lenders often have unconscious biases against female entrepreneurs, affecting their willingness to invest in female-led businesses, according to a 2020 study published in the Journal of Financial Economics, a peer-reviewed financial journal. Also, women might only have restricted access to male-dominated fundraising sources, including crowdfunding websites, angel investors, and VC firms. Similarly, the traditional male dominance in some areas, such as technology and finance, can also lead to power imbalances in fundraising and limit the options available to women.

Insufficient R&D support is another major challenge faced by players in the FemTech sector. This can be seen from the fact that a significant proportion of the funding allocated to healthcare R&D is not focused on issues that directly impact women’s health and well-being, with a meager 4% dedicated to this area according to a 2018 article published in Forbes. This insufficient funding can cause innovation stagnation, set back product development, and reduce market opportunities.

The inadequate representation of women in clinical trials is another difficulty faced by FemTech companies. This lack of representation has created a knowledge gap in understanding important facets of women’s health, such as female anatomy, physiology, health issues, etc. A 2022 study published in Contemporary Clinical Trials, a peer-reviewed journal, showed that though women constitute 50.8% of the US population, just 41.2% of those involved in clinical trials were female. This creates a certain lack of awareness of how women’s bodies work, making it challenging for FemTech businesses to develop effective solutions.

Cybersecurity issues are also creating challenges in the development of FemTech. A joint study by Newcastle University, Royal Holloway, University of London, and ETH Zurich found serious privacy, security, and safety concerns that could put users at risk. The research indicated the danger of leaking sensitive information, such as fertility, medical data, etc., to third parties.

Cultural and social taboos are another bottleneck faced by FemTech companies. Female-specific issues such as postpartum depression and premenstrual syndrome are rarely openly discussed. This makes bringing societal focus to FemTech products a difficult task.

FemTech A Game-Changer in Women's Healthcare by EOS Intelligence

FemTech A Game-Changer in Women’s Healthcare by EOS Intelligence

FemTech industry is seeing significant development in some segments

Though confronting numerous challenges, FemTech remains a promising industry for interested players with its projected market growth. The FemTech market, estimated at US$40.2 billion in 2020, is expected to reach US$75.1 billion in 2025, according to a 2021 report by the US-based market research agency Arizton Advisory & Intelligence.

General health and wellness is the fastest-growing segment

FemTech offers several solutions for improving women’s health across various segments, with general health and wellness companies attracting the most VC investment, followed by reproductive health and contraception.

The general health and wellness segment combines digital health clinics, mental health services, and direct-to-consumer products. Since companies in this segment focus on broad-ranging solutions that address multiple issues, demand for them is expected to rise.

An example is Maven, a New York-based company offering a holistic solution encompassing pre- and post-pregnancy care. This virtual clinic provides 24/7 access to healthcare professionals, including mental health therapists, relationship consultants, and sleep coaches. In 2022, Maven attracted US$300 million in funding from prominent investors and individual strategic partners.

Another example is Stockholm-based Grace Health, acquired by Penda Health, a Kenyan medical care chain in 2023. It uses an automated health assistant called Grace to monitor and understand women’s sexual and reproductive well-being and receive timely reminders and notifications. The company is also expanding its local footprint in key African markets, including Nigeria, Kenya, and Ghana, to solidify its position as a market leader in these regions.

Reproductive health segment is also seeing strong demand

The reproductive health segment and menstruation care are also expected to continue holding the interest of investors and customers alike. According to the NIH, in the USA, 20% of women are now having their first child after turning 35, owing to a greater emphasis on education and career. With increasing age, some women may experience difficulty before, during, or after pregnancy. Women will also need to effectively and accurately track their fertility to make informed reproductive choices. This is likely to greatly contribute to in increased demand for FemTech reproductive health solutions.

An example is the Clue App, a Germany-based fertility tracker that leverages user data to compute and predict individuals’ periods and PMS. In 2023, the company raised US$7.6 million in funding and partnered with global universities such as the University of Exeter to bridge the diagnosis gap for women’s health conditions. This collaboration is expected to create new trends in managing female health issues.

Oncology products are now aimed at individuals and medical professionals

Development is also underway in the oncology segment. An example is Nevada-based Cyrcadia Health developing a breast monitor that tracks changes in breast tissue temperature over time to aid in the detection and risk management of breast cancer. The monitor consists of two patches that track temperature changes and send the data anonymously to the Cyrcadia Health core lab. This data is analyzed using machine learning (ML) algorithms and predictive analytics software to identify and categorize abnormal circadian patterns in healthy breast tissue. The results are then delivered to healthcare providers. This solution, when it becomes available in the market, is expected to enable women to take more proactive control of their breast health.

Cancer continues to be a leading cause of women’s death both in middle-income and high-income countries, according to a 2017 article published in Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers & Prevention, a peer-reviewed journal. Therefore, the focus on FemTech oriented at breast cancer and cancer in general is expected to gain momentum in the future.

Stigmatized conditions and marginalized subpopulations are increasingly addressed

Many FemTech companies are now exploring areas beyond menstrual and reproductive care and addressing stigmatized and unmet conditions such as preterm birth, endometriosis, pelvic care, and sexual health.

An example is London-based Elvie, a company that addresses pelvic floor dysfunction, a common and often overlooked health issue affecting many women. According to the NIH, 27% of women aged 40-59 and 37% of women aged 60-79 experience some form of pelvic floor dysfunction. Elvie has developed a Kegel trainer that uses biofeedback technology to improve pelvic and sexual health through five-minute workouts. The development of these solutions is expected to persuade more women to seek treatment and improve the diagnosis of these health conditions.

Similarly, apps are also being introduced for different sections of the population such as LGBTQ+, black women, and women from low and middle-income societies. US-based InovCares, an app designed to address the crisis of maternal mortality affecting Black women, is an example. This virtual OB-GYN platform connects users with culturally sensitive healthcare professionals who cater to various health needs, including fertility, childbirth, and breastfeeding.

Solutions are being developed in various geographies

While FemTech solutions development is concentrated in the USA and Europe, it is also visible in developing geographies such as Africa and Southeast Asia. An example is Indonesia’s BukuBumil which provides information on various aspects of pregnancy, including fertility, maternal health, baby immunizations, family planning, and post-pregnancy care in the Indonesian language. The platform also allows users to track a baby’s development and milestones.

Another one is Ethiopia-based YeneHealth, a multilingual and culturally responsive platform with AI-powered trackers for menstrual cycle, pregnancy, and medication management.

AI and ML are expected to shape the future of FemTech

Technological advancements are creating waves in the FemTech industry. Many companies are developing smart wearables and AI-powered solutions. Zurich-based Ava Women has developed a wearable, the Ava bracelet (available without prescription), to track hormonal changes. It allows users to monitor their ovulation and detect potential health issues. Ava’s technology uses big data and AI to provide accurate and personalized insights.

Similarly, Ovum, an Australia-based health management app, currently in its pilot phase, offers an AI health assistant designed for women to generate a dataset to improve treatments and diagnostics of various conditions. The app integrates and stores medical records, allowing users to track their health and receive personalized recommendations. This comprehensive data repository is crucial for complex or chronic conditions such as endometriosis, where a diagnosis can take years.

Experts believe the widespread use of AI and ML in FemTech apps will help players provide more accurate and data-driven solutions to users. AI can also analyze large datasets and use predictive analytics to anticipate health risks, such as gestational diabetes or pre-eclampsia.

EOS Perspective

The FemTech landscape, though still developing, is expected to expand more and grow quickly, especially with the increasing discussion around female health, Amazon CTO Werner Vogels commented at the 2023 AWS re:Invent conference, the largest conference in the cloud computing community. He has highlighted the significant potential of FemTech to transform the female healthcare system, specifically considering that women make up 50% of the population and account for 80% of consumer healthcare decisions.

FemTech has also the potential to significantly impact the healthcare sector and the global economy as a whole in the coming years. A 2024 report by the McKinsey Health Institute indicated that improving women’s health could boost the world economy by at least US$1 trillion annually.

The market is expected to see FemTech players widen their business scope, offer multiple services, and address a broader set of health issues. An example of this trend is UK-based Peppy, which initially helped organizations better support their women staff members after they had a baby, but now also deals with menopausal issues. This shift demonstrates a broader approach to women’s health under a single solution and reflects a development towards more comprehensive and inclusive offerings within FemTech.

Since FemTech is still developing, extensive R&D can be expected in the coming years. Experts believe health issues affecting older women also offer interested parties a research investment opportunity. Even now, in discussions and debates regarding FemTech, the diseases suffered by older women get overlooked. This makes it a promising area for future developments.

As the FemTech market expands, it is likely to attract collaborations from players operating outside the healthcare sector. One of the first examples of this was seen in August 2021, when the French cosmetic giant L’Oréal partnered with Clue to research the connection between the menstrual cycle and skin health to improve its skincare products. Such collaborations, whether just publicity stunts for cosmetic companies or not, can help put FemTech solutions on the map of legitimate tools close to women’s health. Considering that FemTech is still considered a niche sector, this can draw attention to the relevance of this market and its players and, consequently, stimulate investment.

Over the long term, women-led companies are expected to create more effective FemTech solutions that identify and cater to women’s unique healthcare requirements. The key factor behind it is that women are better placed to understand the health issues affecting women. A 2022 study published in Harvard Business School’s digital research publication Working Knowledge has also indicated that female-led research teams are more likely to study conditions that impact both genders than male-led ones. With more women stepping into STEM (science, technology, engineering, and mathematics) roles and female-led FemTech start-ups emerging, there is a promise of a more comprehensive scope of FemTech solutions.

A 2023 article published in Harvard Business Review noted an important trend that may positively affect the FemTech market: female investors are more likely to invest in and support female entrepreneurs. This suggests the potential for more capital flowing into women-led businesses, including in FemTech. As more women take on senior leadership roles in both FemTech startups and VC firms, this could substantially propel the industry growth.

Top